How Much Is an Insurance Agency Worth?

How insurance agencies are priced

Two numbers do most of the work. The first is trailing twelve-month commission revenue, normalized to exclude contingent and profit-sharing income — that income is real, but it is volatile and carrier-dependent, so buyers either discount it heavily or value it separately. The second is the EBITDA the book produces once you pay market rates for the people who actually service it. If the seller has been servicing 300 personal-lines accounts personally for free, the buyer has to hire that role back, and the profit picture changes.

The revenue multiple is a convenient shorthand, not a substitute for that arithmetic. An agency at 2x revenue with 60% margins and one at 2x revenue with 20% margins are not the same purchase. For the underlying mechanics — add-backs, SDE versus EBITDA, and working capital at close — see how to value a business and SDE vs EBITDA.

What moves the multiple

• Retention rate — The dominant driver. A book holding above 90% year over year is an annuity a lender will finance comfortably. A book in the low 80s is shedding a fifth of itself annually and needs a materially lower multiple. Ask for retention by policy count as well as by revenue, because carrier rate increases can mask real client attrition.
• Commercial vs. personal lines — Commercial accounts are larger, stickier, and far less exposed to online price shopping. A commercial-heavy book generally earns a premium; a personal auto book competing with direct writers generally does not.
• Carrier appointments — Appointments belong to the agency-carrier relationship, and most carriers require consent on a change of control. An agency with several strong, transferable markets is worth more than one whose volume sits with a single carrier that may not re-appoint the buyer.
• Owner dependence — If the owner personally holds every significant relationship, the book walks out with them. Agencies with licensed producers and account managers who own the client contact trade higher, because the revenue survives the transition.
• Account concentration — A commercial book where the top five accounts are a large share of commission carries obvious risk. Diversified books support higher multiples even at identical revenue.
• Agency management system and data hygiene — A clean AMS with accurate expiration dates and complete policy records is not glamorous, but it is the difference between a buyer who can underwrite the book and one who has to discount it for uncertainty.

What pulls the price down

These are the findings that most often reprice an agency deal between the letter of intent and the closing table. Each one is a reason to bid below the mid-range, or to move part of the price into a seller note or an earnout tied to retention rather than paying it at close.

• Retention that cannot be evidenced from the agency management system.
• Revenue concentrated in contingent or profit-sharing income rather than base commission.
• A single carrier representing a large share of the book, with no written confirmation of re-appointment.
• No non-solicitation agreements with producers who could take accounts with them.
• Errors-and-omissions history, or gaps in E&O coverage, on the tail of past policies.
• A seller unwilling to commit to a real introduction period with the top accounts.

Worked example: a $500,000 commission-revenue agency

An independent agency reports $500,000 of annual commission revenue, split roughly 65% commercial and 35% personal lines, with documented 91% policy-count retention and appointments with five carriers. Owner compensation is $180,000; one licensed account manager handles day-to-day service. At a mid-range 2x revenue that is about $1M.

Adjust up for the commercial weighting, the retention figure, and the fact that the account manager — not the owner — holds most of the day-to-day client contact. Adjust down if the largest carrier will not confirm re-appointment in writing before closing. A realistic structure is a price near the mid-range with 15–25% held back in a seller note or earnout that pays out against a retention threshold measured twelve and twenty-four months after close. That structure is standard in agency deals for a reason: it aligns the seller with the only number that determines whether the buyer got what they paid for.

Run the same arithmetic on any listing you are considering: divide the asking price by trailing commission revenue to get the implied multiple, then ask what in this specific book justifies its position relative to the 1.5x–2.5x range. If nothing does, the price is the seller’s hope rather than the market’s.

Before you rely on any of this

Market ranges orient a first conversation; they do not price a deal. Once you are past the initial screen, get three years of tax returns, a full commission statement history by carrier, and an AMS export showing policy counts and expiration dates. Reconcile the commission statements to the tax returns yourself — that single check catches most of the overstatement in agency listings. Working through our due diligence checklist and verifying the financials before you sign a letter of intent is the cheapest money you will spend on the transaction.

Related Guides